Batista would win I think. Because Batista is just as big, just as strong, just as smart in-ring. And isn't intimidated by anyone, Taker's style is half mental, and Batista wouldn't be feared, so Batista would win I think.
Carlito couldn't fight his way out of a bread basket. An open one at that. But no one wants to hear from his annoying self so it's normally kept closed. And he needs a haircut. Badly.